Looking for honest feedback on collectibles!

What do you like? What don't you like?

I'm very happy seeing how nice the Collectibles Casts rollout is coming out. Something I strongly dislike: they don't have a cannonical, sequential auto-incremental token ID. That's very important for a digital collectible that's meant to preserve a memory of something that happened at a specific point in time.

I work at the posts office

terminally.online

We want to center the cast and its content, not the token. But I get it, we’ll see how it goes.

The way ERC-721 tokens have been used since they 2018 has developed hard habits in the ergonomics of the format. I strongly encourage you talk to people that care a lot about digital collectibles in general and you will find out that this is not minor detail. The token ID is the backbone of a collection.

…but I see, you’re suggesting the time of collection is important. Hard to change now but should be available to indexers.