@odysseyheart
So, I’ve finished reading Katabasis and, since you asked, I wanted to share a few thoughts. This is a very personal take (just my opinion) so please don’t take it personally.
I want to start by saying that I really like R.F. Kuang as an author. I’ve read Yellowface and Babel, and because of that I went into this book with fairly high expectations. Unfortunately, Katabasis felt a bit underwhelming to me.
The characters are not fully developed, and the story overall feels unpolished, almost as if it was written in a rush. The core idea is actually very interesting, and the dark academia atmosphere really worked for me (probably because of my own background and studies). That part genuinely pulled me in.
However, once the story moves into Hell, it started to lose its grip on me. Ironically, the infernal setting felt weaker than the academic one, and that was a major turn-off. I also think I would have preferred this story without the romance element, which didn’t fully convince me.
Overall, it’s not a bad book, but it’s not Kuang’s best either. If you’re interested in this author, I would still strongly recommend Yellowface and Babel.
Have you read this? Anything else from this author? Thoughts?