It is very clear that the only way mini apps are going to work is to have one standardized testing environment. If a mini app works in this testing environment and not your farcaster client, then that is a bug in your client not the mini app. It will be increasingly unfeasible for mini app devs to debug every farcaster client separately

Team is looking to solve any interoperability paper cuts

Goal with mini apps is write once, deploy everywhere. No extra work required!

if you are building a mini app and are experiencing any compatiiblity issues between base and farcaster please respond with:

1. if you are using miniapp-sdk or minikit (base sdk)
2. what the problem is

please share as these come up, we are very focused on ensuring this is a good experience

please share as these come up, we are very focused on ensuring this is a good experience

https://farcaster.xyz/dwr.eth/0xd9be11e7
https://farcaster.xyz/deodad/0x90352452

It has dawned on me that as the creator of /tortoise I should probably upload all my music there.

I’m starting with a song called Lazy River. I released this in 2022 originally as part of a four song EP called Serene Wrap.

This is before I picked up guitar as my main writing tool, so it’s more piano/synthesizer based than other stuff you might have hear from me

There is a strange issue with collections on the original upload here because it was uploaded with base app. Investigating. I have reuploaded from farcastapp if you would like to collect tortoise.studio/song/lazy-river-2

I know yall are working on it and appreciate it! I am really struggling with getting song uploads to work on base app. I can't find any discrepencies between the create song transactions or data uploads between base app and farcaster app, but uploads from base app can't be collected. I've been combing through the logs in base app using eruda all morning(nightmare) and can't find a single discrepency in the transactions. Here is the upload from base app https://farcaster.xyz/mattlee/0xe37340c8

And here's the tx logs from that given to me by @pirosb3 

here's an upload from farcastapp which works fine

Engineer @farcaster, co-founder @bountycaster. Sharing what I learn about AI + development. Previously: Phantom, 0x. NYC 🗽

I work at the posts office

terminally.online

Forgot the tx logs

{
  "validation": {
    "status": "Error",
    "result_type": "Error",
    "description": "",
    "reason": "",
    "features": [],
    "error": "Simulation Error: Reverted",
    "labels": []
  },
  "simulation": {
    "status": "Error",
    "error": "Reverted"
  },
  "gas_estimation": {
    "status": "Error",
    "error": "Simulation Error: Reverted"
  },
  "block": "32999222",
  "chain": "base",
  "account_address": "0x1CeE629CeB06538874f30ead124c004CECBEb089"
}

Also I recognize this is probably impossible to debug from your end all good I figured sharing this experience is still helpful for you

I know yall are working on it and appreciate it! I am really struggling with getting song uploads to work on base app. I can't find any discrepencies between the create song transactions or data uploads between base app and farcaster app, but uploads from base app can't be collected. I've been combing through the logs in base app using eruda all morning(nightmare) and can't find a single discrepency in the transactions. Here is the upload from base app https://farcaster.xyz/mattlee/0xe37340c8

And here's the tx logs from that given to me by @pirosb3 

here's an upload from farcastapp which works fine https://farcaster.xyz/mattlee/0x6419873e