@michaelcjoseph
Follow up with the next test: Flappy Bird.
Windsurf was significantly better than Cursor here.
Windsurf: 90% success rate
- Design was decent. Bird looked like a bird and pipes had some definition.
- Collision detection was pretty good, but very conservative. If you were close to the pipe, it considered it game over.
- Up and down motion was a little jumpy. Could have been smoother.
- Functional scoring.
Cursor: 50% of the way there
- Design was very basic. The bird was just a ball and pipes were simply green cylinders.
- The pipes don't even appear until about two seconds into the game.
- Collision detection was completely broken. Even if you were to completely avoid a pipe, the game would end.
- Scoring did not work.
- Up and down motion and gravity in general was way smoother than Windsurf though.