chomu
8mo
Member
Clip - Product Feedback ?
--------------------
Drop (a) product feedback, (b) feature ideas, or (c) Reddit frustrations in the comments.
About Clip:
ELI5: Like Reddit, but people earn from posting and commenting
Our goal is to find PMF i.e answer these 3 questions:
1. Crypto-Native: Is /c/crypto fun enough for daily use (readers + traders)?
2. Normie-Friendly: Can we grow channels beyond crypto?
3. Scalable Playbook: Can we repeatedly launch high-quality, positive-sum channels?
After PMF:
Go after Reddit with the first major Web3 “vampire attack.”
Risks:
1. Smart contracts are currently unaudited. Ape responsibly.
2. We’re in Beta and shipping fast: expect bugs.
1. I didn't understand if the funds earned by the comments come exclusively from trading fees / creator earnings? or does the creator of the post add funds when creating a post, almost like a bounty to get good feedback? or both?
2. What use case do you see for this first? Crypto traders sharing alpha/advice? I would focus on one use case only to test the idea, but not sure what that could be
4
49
@macedo.eth You earned $122 worth of ETH for this comment on Clip. Go to theclip.fun to claim it.
Thanks for commenting on the 1st post on Clip, and your feedback
4
2
nevermind, already found how to claim
but having to send $0.01 to the clip embedded wallet will create some friction...can't you use Base's paymaster to sponsor gas?
1
2
This is cool conceptually but needs some serious additional thought in terms of onboarding (must be seamless, shouldn’t require email, should be able to auth with Warpcast or wallet) as well as UX/UI design.
Right now, the interface feels disjointed - more emphasis on where a user should be looking, more “flow” from step to step, an optional dark mode (maybe even enabled by default…?) and some splashes of color would go a long way.
There’s room to make this more exciting and fun to engage with. I also wonder if this might work better as a PWA, vs in browser only? Or perhaps even better than that - deploy it as a Farcaster Mini App (formerly Frames)
The concept is strong, I see the vision… I just think some more thought is needed to make this accessible, fun, sleek, attractive, and engaging, such that people log in and use the platform but also keep coming back.
Good luck, strong start conceptually!!
1
19
@greyseymour: You earned $26 worth of ETH for your this comment on Clip.
Go to theclip.fun to claim it.
You are killing it :)
lol one more comment - this will be my third, emphasizing how valuable an edit comment option might be, but otherwise: consider letting users attach media! If I can include a screenshot or a short video or gif, I can visually impart my feedback/express myself better!
ok, I’m done now, no more lol
14
A few rapid fire additions in addendum to my much longer comment I left -
1. Need to be able to customize my user profile.
2. Need to be able to edit comments here once posted.
3. Elements like “earn up to X” should be clickable
4. More clarity could be added as to why that dialogue goes from “earn up to [amount]” to “earn up to $0” - maybe a tooltip, or make it clickable - something. Maybe even remove the dialogue after the first comment is made??? As it stands right now where you cannot edit comments, if a commenter thinks of a great suggestion after their first comment, they’re now being disincentivized to post it!
2
13
@pichi : You earned $15 worth of ETH for this comment on Clip. Go to theclip.fun to claim it.
Thanks for commenting on the 1st post on Clip.
1
As a content creator (mainly video-based) i'm VERY excited to see the experiment grow - would love to start testing it out! Anywhere here are my answers:
1. Crypto-Native: Is /c/crypto fun enough for daily use (readers + traders)?
Considering i might get paid bookoo bucks for posting here - then yea definetley for crypto natives
2. Normie-Friendly: Can we grow channels beyond crypto?
yes BUT crypto needs to fade into the back end, and payments/anyhting value-related should not showcase crypto in any way - just the dollar amounts without mention of crypto - the masses dont care, they just want to find enjoyable content
3. Scalable Playbook: Can we repeatedly launch high-quality, positive-sum channels?
yes but u need the right folks/ideally creators that have an incentive to build up their own account + their own channel
1
1
@bfresh you have $0 worth of ETH pending to be claimed for your comment earnings.
You can claim your earnings from your profile section on Clip
@garrett :You earned $10 worth of ETH for your this comment on Clip.
Go to theclip.fun to claim it.
Thanks for commenting on the 1st post on Clip, and hopefully, we can build c/crypto into a fun channel.
Would love to invite you to become a member of c/crypto so you can post on the channel too. LMK if you are interested
1
@codincowboy : You earned $86 worth of ETH for this comment on Clip. Go to theclip.fun to claim it.
Always happy to see a mfer win.
Hopefully, we can build a fun c/crypto channel together.
1
1
curious to see how the coinbase client will look like after x months
i really like the following at the moment:
- how it presents mini apps
- chat ui
- how it surfaces video content
what i would like to see:
- posting in channels
- better cast embeds (ex: youtube links)
- bookmarks
- ability to sort thru (home, following, trending)
- desktop client
2
20
@kylepatrick.eth :You earned $40 worth of ETH for this comment on Clip. Go to theclip.fun to claim it.
Thanks for commenting on the 1st post on Clip, and your feedback.
Hopefully, we can build a fun c/crypto channel together.
1
1
@gtm: You earned ~$50worth of ETH for this comment on Clip.
Go to theclip.fun to claim it.
Making a video for feedback is dope. Really appreciated your feedback.
Hopefully, we can build a fun c/crypto channel together.
1