Community or Cult, Your Choice

By Arjan | TPG - That Poetry Guy

One day, in my mid-teens, I traveled to Amsterdam to spend a weekend with one of my big sisters. Most of my family lived in or near The Hague, just not this sister. She moved to Amsterdam, lived in a squatted former school and was a bit different. She took me out to the city, that weekend. Proper out. And one of the places we went to was the Bhagwan Disco. A club owned by the Bhagwan community. It was open to others, but not just anybody. The atmosphere in this disco was generally very good. It was less raw than other places in the Amsterdam nightlife. A positive place, even though it felt a bit strange to be there. The Bhagwan community was at the time the most infamous cult, with an autocratic leader and followers dressed in red/purple clothing. It thrived for a while, even able to set up town-sized communities all over the world. Beneath the positive shine of the Bhagwan disco, and the apparently prospering communities, it remained a cult, with one leader and his clique deciding for all the followers how to live.

When the book Communistic Societies of the United States was announced as the next read for the Farcaster book club, it was the image of the Bhagwan that came to mind. Maybe David Koresh as well. And the Amish, also, who are maybe the most enduring communistic society. I found that contradictory to the idea of a techno-positive network state, so I asked my good friend ChatGPT to analyse the book for me. Pros and cons. His response is what you can read below.

Nordhoff examines communities that deliberately attempted to organise economic and social life according to principles different from those of mainstream American capitalism. Some were religious, some were secular, and others combined religious beliefs with communal ownership and collective labour.

The central question running through the book is:

Can people organise themselves into communities based on shared property, collective responsibility and common values, while achieving economic prosperity and social stability?

Nordhoff's book is valuable because he does not merely speculate about this question. He visits the communities, observes their daily lives, examines their economic arrangements and reports on their achievements and difficulties.

One important qualification before we begin: the word communistic in the title should not be understood as referring exclusively to modern Marxist communism. Nordhoff uses it much more broadly to describe communities organised around forms of common property, shared production and collective living.

Let's examine the book in the same structured way as the previous two.

1. What is the central argument of the book?

Nordhoff's underlying interest is the condition of labour and the possibility of improving workers' lives through alternative economic arrangements.

His starting point is that ordinary wage labour has serious limitations.

In conventional employment, workers generally receive wages for their labour but do not necessarily share in the ownership of the enterprise or the benefits generated by its long-term success.

Nordhoff contrasts this with communal societies, in which members may jointly own productive assets, share responsibilities and participate in the economic life of their community.

His argument is that these arrangements can produce several advantages:

Importantly, Nordhoff is not simply presenting a philosophical defence of communism.

He is interested in whether these communities actually work.

Do they produce sufficient wealth? Are their members healthy and prosperous? How do they organise labour? What happens to individual freedom? How do they maintain discipline and resolve disagreements?

These practical questions make the book particularly interesting.

His investigation covers a wide range of communities, including the Amana Society, the Harmonists, the Shakers, the Oneida Community, the Icarians and several smaller settlements.

2. The communities Nordhoff examines

One of the great strengths of the book is that Nordhoff does not treat communal living as a single model. He examines quite different experiments, with different religious beliefs, economic arrangements and systems of governance.

Here are the most important examples.

1. Amana Society (Iowa)

A German religious community organised around shared property, collective labour and a highly structured communal life.

Its members shared agricultural and industrial production, lived in organised villages and maintained a strong religious identity.

It is an interesting example of communal ownership combined with relatively successful commercial activity.

2. The Harmonists (Economy, Pennsylvania)

Founded under the leadership of George Rapp, this community combined religious discipline, common property and extensive economic activity.

Its members developed successful agricultural and manufacturing enterprises.

It illustrates the importance of strong leadership and organisational discipline in communal societies.

3. Zoar (Ohio)

Another German religious community, founded by separatists who sought freedom from religious persecution.

The community organised property and productive activity collectively and developed a relatively successful agricultural economy.

It is particularly interesting for understanding the relationship between religious solidarity and economic cooperation.

4. The Shakers

Perhaps the best-known example.

The Shakers practised communal ownership, celibacy, collective labour and strict religious discipline.

They developed highly organised agricultural and manufacturing activities and became known for their craftsmanship.

Their approach to gender relations and family life makes them particularly interesting from a sociological perspective.

5. Oneida Community (New York)

Founded by John Humphrey Noyes, Oneida combined communal property with highly unconventional religious and social arrangements.

Its system included complex marriage, collective child-rearing and an emphasis on spiritual perfection.

It also developed successful manufacturing businesses.

Oneida is especially important because it challenges conventional assumptions about marriage, property, sexuality and family organisation.

6. Bishop Hill Colony (Illinois)

Founded by Swedish immigrants under the religious leadership of Erik Jansson.

It attempted to establish collective ownership and production but experienced serious organisational and financial difficulties.

It is especially useful as a contrasting example because Nordhoff examines the causes of its failure.

7. The Icarians

Inspired by Étienne Cabet's vision of an egalitarian society, the Icarians attempted to put a more explicitly secular and socialist vision of communal life into practice.

Their experience is important for comparing religiously motivated communities with communities based on political and social ideals.

The full book also examines Aurora, Bethel, Cedar Vale and other settlements. Nordhoff even includes three colonies that he explicitly classifies as not communistic, providing a useful comparison with more conventional forms of cooperative settlement.

3. The strong points of Nordhoff's argument

A. He moves the debate from ideology to practical experience

This is probably the most important contribution of the book.

Discussions about communism and socialism in the nineteenth century were often dominated by ideological arguments.

Supporters argued that collective ownership would eliminate exploitation and inequality.

Opponents argued that people would lose their incentive to work, that collective ownership would undermine individual responsibility and that communal arrangements would ultimately fail.

Nordhoff takes a different approach.

He essentially asks: what actually happens when people attempt to organise their lives this way?

He examines:

This makes his book an early and valuable contribution to the empirical study of alternative economic institutions.

Rather than asking whether communism is theoretically desirable, he asks whether particular forms of communal organisation are workable.

B. He identifies the importance of shared economic interests

Nordhoff makes an interesting argument about incentives.

In conventional wage employment, workers may have relatively little direct interest in the long-term success of the enterprise.

They receive wages regardless of whether the enterprise becomes substantially more profitable.

In a communal organisation, however, members are also participants in the collective enterprise.

They have a shared interest in maintaining productive assets, improving economic performance and ensuring the community's long-term survival.

Nordhoff argues that this can create a stronger connection between individual effort and collective prosperity.

He challenges the assumption that people only work efficiently when they receive an individually determined financial reward.

This is a surprisingly modern argument, closely related to discussions of:

His discussion anticipates an important question in organisational economics:

Does ownership influence people's willingness to contribute to productive activity?

C. He recognises the importance of institutional organisation

Another strength is that Nordhoff understands that shared ownership alone is insufficient.

Successful communities require institutional arrangements.

They need:

This is an important insight.

A community may have admirable ideals, but without workable organisational structures it will struggle to survive.

Nordhoff's descriptions of the administrative arrangements at Amana, Economy and Oneida illustrate how different communities attempted to solve these problems.

D. He demonstrates that collective ownership does not necessarily mean economic inefficiency

One of the most interesting findings is that several communal societies achieved considerable economic success.

Some operated farms, workshops, factories and commercial enterprises.

They produced goods for external markets and accumulated productive assets.

This challenges the simplistic argument that collective ownership must inevitably result in poor economic performance.

The communities demonstrate that collective property and market participation can coexist.

Indeed, many of these societies were not isolated from capitalism. They sold products, purchased inputs, employed external labour and participated in wider commercial networks.

This is an important distinction.

Communal ownership does not necessarily require economic isolation.

E. He recognises the importance of social cohesion and shared values

Nordhoff also observes that successful communities often possess a strong sense of common purpose.

Religion, shared identity and collective discipline can help sustain cooperation.

This is important because economic cooperation involves more than financial incentives.

Trust, social expectations, shared beliefs and mutual obligations can all reduce the costs of organising collective activity.

A community in which members trust one another may find it easier to coordinate production and resolve disagreements than one in which everyone is primarily concerned with individual advantage.

This is a particularly interesting contribution to the study of social capital.

F. He provides an unusually rich empirical record

There is also an important historical contribution.

Nordhoff describes societies that might otherwise be poorly documented.

His observations include their buildings, industries, daily routines, religious practices, family arrangements, schools, governance systems and financial organisation.

He even provides comparative statistics.

The book therefore functions as a valuable historical record of nineteenth-century American communal life.

Later historians have continued to use it as a source, although it must be read alongside other evidence. The Amana Heritage Society, for example, describes Nordhoff's account of Amana as an exceptionally valuable nineteenth-century description.

Communal Studies Association+1

4. The weaknesses and criticisms

This is where the book becomes particularly interesting.

Nordhoff is an unusually observant journalist, but he is not a neutral observer in the modern academic sense. His political and economic assumptions influence how he evaluates the communities.

I would identify seven major weaknesses or limitations.

A. Nordhoff has a strong ideological bias concerning labour and trade unions

This is probably the most important criticism of the book.

At first glance, Nordhoff appears to be a sympathetic observer of communal ownership.

He believes that collective economic arrangements can improve the position of workers.

However, his underlying political philosophy is not particularly egalitarian or anti-capitalist.

In his introduction, he argues that the most desirable outcome for workers is to escape wage dependence and become independent owners of capital.

He is also remarkably hostile towards trade unions.

He describes them as harmful to society, arguing that they encourage conflict between labour and capital and undermine individual economic independence.

This is an important contradiction.

Nordhoff supports communal arrangements, but he does not necessarily support collective labour organisation in the conventional trade-union sense.

His preferred solution is closer to independent economic ownership through cooperation.

In other words, he wants workers to become economically independent rather than organise themselves primarily as a class of wage earners.

This creates a particular ideological framework through which he evaluates the communities.

He tends to admire those that demonstrate economic independence, productive efficiency and self-discipline.

He is much less interested in whether their arrangements produce equality in a broader social or political sense.

His introduction makes this position quite explicit.

B. He sometimes confuses economic success with social success

This is a particularly important criticism.

Nordhoff places considerable emphasis on economic performance.

He examines whether communities:

These are legitimate measures of success.

But are they sufficient?

Imagine two communities.

Community A is economically prosperous but has highly authoritarian leadership, limited individual freedom and strict restrictions on personal behaviour.

Community B is less prosperous but provides its members with greater individual autonomy, political participation and personal freedom.

Which community is more successful?

Nordhoff's framework does not always provide a satisfactory answer.

He tends to regard economic prosperity, social stability and discipline as important indicators of successful communal organisation.

But these indicators do not necessarily tell us whether members are genuinely free or whether the distribution of power is equitable.

This raises a fundamental methodological problem:

A community can be economically successful without necessarily being socially or politically desirable.

C. The problem of authority and individual freedom

Many of the communities Nordhoff examines relied on strong leadership and extensive internal regulation.

Consider the Harmonists under George Rapp.

The community achieved considerable economic success, but its organisation was highly hierarchical.

Similarly, the Shakers maintained strict rules governing:

The Oneida Community also operated under a powerful leadership structure, despite its unconventional social arrangements.

These examples reveal an important tension.

Collective ownership may reduce dependence on external employers, but it does not necessarily eliminate internal power inequalities.

Indeed, the authority of community leaders can become extremely influential when they control access to property, housing, employment and the distribution of resources.

The relevant question is therefore not simply whether property is privately or collectively owned.

It is also:

Who controls the collective property, and who has the authority to make decisions about its use?

This is a question that deserves more attention than Nordhoff sometimes gives it.

Later scholarship on the Shakers, for example, has challenged romanticised accounts of their harmonious communal life, documenting complex authority structures, internal disagreements and institutional conflicts.

D. The question of gender equality is insufficiently addressed

This is another area where contemporary scholarship provides a much more nuanced perspective.

Some of the communities Nordhoff examines offered women opportunities that were unusual for nineteenth-century American society.

The Shakers, for example, developed a system in which women could hold religious leadership positions alongside men.

Oneida also experimented with unconventional arrangements concerning marriage, sexuality and family life.

But these developments should not automatically be interpreted as evidence of gender equality.

Consider the Shakers.

Although they maintained an important principle of spiritual equality between men and women, their daily lives remained highly regulated, with many occupations divided along gender lines.

At Amana, Nordhoff himself describes a strong separation between men and women and significant restrictions on social interaction.

The broader question is whether communal ownership actually transformed gender relations or simply reorganised existing inequalities within a different institutional structure.

There is also a question of who controlled reproductive decisions, household responsibilities and the social expectations imposed on women.

Later scholarship has placed much greater emphasis on women's experiences within these communities, rather than relying primarily on the descriptions of male observers or institutional leaders.

E. He underestimates the problem of membership selection

This is one of the most interesting criticisms from the perspective of institutional economics.

Nordhoff observes that some communal societies work remarkably well.

But we should ask: who becomes a member of these communities in the first place?

Many of them were not open associations in which anyone could simply arrive and participate.

They often required:

In other words, they selected for people who were already relatively committed to the community's objectives.

This raises a problem of selection bias.

A community made up of people with unusually strong shared values, high levels of commitment and a willingness to sacrifice individual preferences may function very differently from a community made up of a randomly selected population.

We should therefore be cautious about generalising from their success.

A successful religious commune does not necessarily demonstrate that the same economic arrangements would work equally well in a large, diverse society.

This is an important distinction between the viability of small intentional communities and the viability of an entire economic system.

F. He does not fully resolve the problem of long-term sustainability

Some communities were prosperous when Nordhoff visited them.

But economic success at a particular moment does not necessarily establish long-term sustainability.

There are several issues here:

The Shakers provide an excellent example.

They developed sophisticated productive systems and achieved considerable economic success.

Yet their commitment to celibacy meant that they depended on recruitment to maintain their population.

Over time, membership declined.

This illustrates the difference between economic sustainability and demographic sustainability.

A community may have an efficient economic organisation but still struggle to reproduce itself socially.

Research by Coşgel and Andrew (2001), examining Shaker membership between 1850 and 1870, demonstrates the importance of religious, social and economic factors in understanding membership persistence and decline.

G. The book is rooted in the assumptions of nineteenth-century American expansion

There is one additional historical limitation that I think deserves particular attention.

Nordhoff repeatedly presents access to inexpensive and fertile land as an important route towards economic independence for American workers.

He even describes the availability of land as a safety valve for social discontent.

This is understandable within the political economy of nineteenth-century America.

However, it overlooks a fundamental historical issue: much of this land was not simply vacant or unused.

It was part of Indigenous territories and had been subjected to dispossession through settlement, treaties, coercion and state expansion.

This matters because Nordhoff's argument about economic independence is partly dependent on an expanding frontier.

The opportunity for some settlers to acquire land was connected to a much broader history of territorial expansion and Indigenous dispossession.

Consequently, the apparent independence of the American worker cannot be considered entirely separately from the historical distribution of land and political power.

This is an important limitation when evaluating Nordhoff's broader vision of American economic opportunity.

5. What does the broader historical scholarship tell us?

One important development since Nordhoff's time is that historians have moved beyond simply asking whether communal societies succeeded or failed.

They increasingly examine the internal experiences of their members and the relationship between communal institutions and wider American society.

Three developments are particularly important.

First: the history of gender and family relations.

Historians have examined how communal societies reorganised marriage, sexuality, reproduction and women's participation in economic and religious life.

The work of Lawrence Foster is particularly relevant here.

His Women, Family, and Utopia (1991) examines the Shakers, Oneida and the Mormons, showing how alternative family arrangements were connected to broader experiments in social organisation.

Second: the relationship between religious authority and communal organisation.

Stephen J. Stein's The Shaker Experience in America (1992) is particularly valuable.

Stein challenges the romantic image of the Shakers as simply peaceful, harmonious communities.

He examines their leadership structures, internal conflicts, institutional development and adaptation to changing circumstances.

This provides a much more complex understanding of communal life.

Third: the importance of historical development and institutional adaptation.

Amy Hart's 2019 survey of scholarship on nineteenth-century religious communal experiments shows how the field has evolved.

Rather than concentrating exclusively on the most famous communities, historians have increasingly explored race, gender, membership, institutional change and the experiences of ordinary participants.

The emphasis has shifted from judging whether a utopian experiment succeeded or failed towards understanding how these communities actually functioned and changed over time.

6. Summary: strong versus weak points

Here is how I would organise the arguments for an academic discussion.

7. My overall assessment: where is the real contribution?

I would distinguish between three propositions in Nordhoff's argument.

First: collective ownership can work economically.

This is perhaps his strongest contribution.

He provides concrete evidence that communities can organise productive activity, operate commercial enterprises and maintain relatively high standards of living without relying exclusively on conventional private ownership.

This is an important challenge to the assumption that individual ownership is the only viable basis for economic productivity.

Second: collective ownership can create stronger social and economic relationships.

This is also plausible.

Shared ownership can create common interests, encourage cooperation and reduce certain conflicts between employers and employees.

However, the success of these arrangements depends heavily on trust, membership selection, governance and shared values.

Third: communal ownership produces a better society.

This is the most problematic proposition.

Economic prosperity does not necessarily imply equality, individual freedom or democratic participation.

A community may be economically successful while maintaining highly restrictive social arrangements.

The distinction between economic performance and social desirability is therefore essential.

My interpretation is that Nordhoff is most convincing when he describes what he actually observes and less convincing when he generalises from these observations into broader conclusions about labour, capitalism and society.

8. Five questions to keep in mind while reading

These are the questions I would use to guide a critical reading of the book:

1. Efficiency: Does collective ownership genuinely improve productive efficiency, or does it depend on particular characteristics of the people who choose to participate?

2. Incentives: Can shared economic interests replace individual financial incentives, and under what conditions?

3. Governance: Does collective ownership necessarily distribute power more equally, or can it simply transfer power from private owners to communal leaders?

4. Freedom: How much individual autonomy can be sacrificed in exchange for economic security, social cohesion and collective prosperity?

5. Sustainability: Can communal institutions survive changes in leadership, demographic pressures, generational differences and external economic conditions?

These questions help distinguish the economic, institutional and social dimensions of Nordhoff's argument.

9. One final thought: the tension between community and individual freedom

There is one question that I think captures the deepest philosophical issue in this book.

Nordhoff is interested in whether people can escape economic dependence by organising production collectively.

But this creates a paradox.

By joining a communal society, individuals may become less dependent on external employers and private capital owners.

At the same time, they may become more dependent on the internal institutions and leadership of their community.

The question therefore becomes:

Does collective ownership necessarily increase individual independence, or does it simply change the nature and location of economic dependence?

I think this is the most interesting way to approach Nordhoff critically.

It also connects directly to a much broader debate in political economy: the relationship between economic security, property rights, individual liberty and collective responsibility.

My overall conclusion: Nordhoff's enduring contribution is to demonstrate that alternative forms of economic organisation are not merely theoretical possibilities. They have existed, functioned and sometimes prospered. His limitation is that he does not always distinguish sufficiently between economic success, social cohesion, individual freedom and equality.